02-18-14 Agenda PacketCity of Poway OF POW
r
MEMORANDUM
a CI•INTHE•tlCO
ADDITIONALMATERIAL
DATE: February 18, 2014
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
FROM: Tina White, Interim City ManagerpP
INITIATED BY: Robert J. Manis, Director ofDevelopment Services
SUBJECT: Workshop on Amateur Radio Antenna Regulations
The purpose of this memorandum is to clarify the staff - recommended proposal
regarding the total number of allowed antennas and antennasupport structures and
those that would be exempted from the requirement for a Minor Development Review
Application (MDRA) or Minor Conditional Use Permit (MCUP).
The proposalwould allowtwo exempt antenna support structures with an unlimited
numberof antennas attached to them. One could be roof mounted and one be ground
mounted. Both would be limited to 35 feet in height (combinedstructure and antennas,
measuredfrom the ground) with the support structure limited to 4 inches in
diameter. Thesewould notrequire a discretionary permit. In addition to the exempt
antenna supportstructures, one additional non - exempt antenna support structure could
be allowed with a MDRApermit or a MCUP, depending on the height of the combined
antennasupport structure and attachedantenna(s).
The summarytable included with the agenda report has been updated and is included
as Attachment A.
Additionally, staff has updatedthesurvey of other jurisdictions' regulations to include
the regulationsproposed for Poway to better assist in comparison.
Attachments
A. Updated Summaryof Proposed Regulations
B. Updated Survey ofOtherJurisdictions
1 of 6 February 18, 2014 Item #5.1
2 of 6
ATTACHMENT A
February 18, 2014 Item #5.1
DQ
0 (1) 3 Q o Q
0
L0°
n o CLCL L) Qom M -0
o
Q Q
tn c6 c Q. in N NN N in O t O O
p O O p
Q
yN
O+
a)
L C p CC "- C "- C O CO C "' Q L
O
C N O M. LoO
C + 3
V
o
O.
V d NNa) c O O
c O C
QO.0 L)
a) C
C QN.. CYCQ- XE
OO
J 0 (B 0 (n Z cucn
O>
N O
O
Q O U
a)
cn L
O = a) N Q O to a) — L co M cn Q to .
c cn
CL
r
W,A
E W O cu O Q
U
U i U N
0
0- N Q O
p p CU U)
O O)
a) r- OiOa) LO -
cy)
O
3
C `. O a) cn Q . O Q . - O
75 cu
cn .0 O " a)
E v_ NC. In Q «s U C CU
C O O 0 0 Q M p a) fB M NC >' C p C N
d C U a) 0. w c-
0
Q C p) E U C r+ "- , UO B C
O O O B a) L a) c O ca O U
ar L)XC Q 3 c :c: a-., c
O` pp (n M a) N O M a) . N U p C C
C co co M O N 0 M O Co O (1) OLM O c p O 6
Qp M OmowMM
C O 0
O
O
U Q O
C N O O N
O
E Q
o c . `- C
3 cv
c
c_0 0 Q-
a) U .c
0 o -c 0-a
L
Q a) p E N L cn O C C L f4 C EEa)a) a) a)
d Oa). .a) cQ W0 0a) -0 00 0a) NWo
C m U C a) cn U p 3: U EE E a) U pD a) cn c) c) E w- IOOa)
XX C p X 0 Q U L O O p U L a) , a)
a) L Q. cu a) i In In
N Q (n N a) W (a , W Z A U n E (n Z L U (n a a OO O n M c 7
0 0 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
X_
0 N Q L
A Qa) QW
QUO c: O
y-..
B > OO
N a) U
CN
O — a)
C
C O. C L E O pMN -a "-'
a) -•
V
O
O
x c:
a) a)
W O CD E) 00 00 c Q M
M cn co 30) Z U Q C RS U
0 0 0
s
p
c O
U_
Q EO
EUa) X
0-0 2
2 of 6
ATTACHMENT A
February 18, 2014 Item #5.1
3 of 6 February 18, 2014 Item #5.1
L Q a)
d A+ ++= Q O N O p L M M U ..
4a
ca O
MC++ c0
Q U A
o''' C Y
0 C
C''_
3 C
a)
c
c
cn + OUN v CU O N
LO
cc E cn
E
Q.
p) E M a) L a) E ca
c
O C .E
a c L
C c0
cC 0 O
t4
a)
LO
p C
J
C
0 a) C a) a) Q
D-
o
U
O
Q,.
V d OO O
C
c L •'
n
O
a)
C
a) C X
F— ca a)
c Q a)
Q cn p t
J Z Z Q )3:
pNN Z M
o 0 0
A ca
3
L
3 0 0 00 3
C L L C Y L) C Y InL
d Q
i
O O U
L
C O -• CU U O
Eo
O
L
C`
O M
C`
O a)
ca
C b 0 C L a) 0 0
C`
O cuOV ( V NN M inin Q Q- cA C N V toVd
e e o
C
c-
C O U
O
E
p Q a) C
C
O 4) C
a)
O N 0 O E EC
0 O'
M O X
a) a O
0U
r,
p
C .
C
c cg M
C
cn MM
U O 0 O c O
O U fn
cn C
O E a) cpa) U
N O
L
O
C L
CD _U L-
C C
Q
N 0 E cn 4?.cn p
a cn' CU -0 O U O to U OL EL C EL cnOCa)
N O N
C C
cB
C N
0
C6 '
O
p
O U O
C C
CU
O) 0 00)
O
c0
CU M
n
CC C OL a U
0
a C
d
E c
Ncn E Y
C Q)
C6
E O 0 0- .0
a) c
C
E O U a) C Q C
ca Q M
M Q c0
CL -0 a) a) O O
o
ca
O
Ca) ca O a) •Q c C a) O Z'
D
C N E N 2 CCOowOEcn
M Ca
U) C
O
C
LO L
a)
LdO .- fn .NN
in C ,._,
3
c0 +.
CE E
a)
X
a)
C L
YCCU a) a) p c
M
pCOL C co O. E
L o
D E
C
Lm _
C
C a) a i"J o a i o M" o o o acl
E a) 0 O C O p C ."- O C O a) L c "= Q D .. Q a) X
O— L c«= Z M Z C Q 3 N Q LO N O O U) O N =3 F- a)
e 0 s s 0 0 s
L
a)
0
a)
3
00C 6 o
N EO3Q-
N
cn
UO U cu N a)
C
W d p E p U p
Z _ F— v con N Z
0 0 0
o a
ca C
N cn
Q) C C
c c Q U
U
O
Q CC
E c c pQ U
E Q.s a) 5-
z<<U)CA(A LU<< Cl) Cn
3 of 6 February 18, 2014 Item #5.1
L Q
C a
ca p C o ca U
M g
Q E d Q. U
N
a)
L6
0
O
E
N
d j a N
a c6 Q
v O Q O 5 in
U o c m p
0
O
t+ r
C
Ec d Q O
G L
c
U CL
N
C
O
7
O
d
C
d
O
V
d
c
N
N
0 p
N
x
W m
o
o
Z
O
c
0
cuL
U) c
OO
UU
4 of 6 February 18, 2014 Item #5.1
Amateur Radio Antenna Standards in San Diego County
City Type of Discretionary Maximum AntennaAntenna
Permit(s) Height Support Number
Limit Structure
Location
Carlsbad None No LimitNot in required No limit
building
setbacks
Coronado None for antennas up to 66 feet No Limit Not in required No limit
in height, Special Use Permit for building
over 66 feet setbacks
Chula Vista None No limit No locational No limit
requirements
Del Mar DesignReview Permit 26' ground, Subject to Design
36' roof Design Review Review
Encinitas None for antennas up to 100 No Limit Not in required No limit
feet in height, Major Use Permit front yard
MUP) if over 100 feet setback
Escondido None No Limit Not in required No limit
building
setbacks
La Mesa None for antennas up to 15 feet No Limit Not in required No limit
in height, CUP for over 15 feet front yard
setback
Lemon None forantennas up to 100 No Limit Not in required No limit
Grove feet in height, CUP if over 100 front yard
feet setback
Oceanside None for freestanding antennas No Limit Not in required No limit
up to 51 feet and roof - mounted building
antennas up to 15 feet, CUP for setbacks
over 51 feet freestanding /over
15 feet on roof - mounted
Poway None for 2 exempted types; No Limit Not in required No Limit
proposed) For non-exempt; building
MDRA up to 35 feet setbacks
MCUP for 35 -50 feet
MCUP forover 50 feet with
special findings
San Diego None No limit Not in required No limit
City) building
setbacks
San Diego None for antennas up to200 No limit Not in required No limit
County feet in height, MUP for over 200 building
feet setbacks
San Marcos None forantennas up to 60 feet No Limit Not in required No limit
in height, CUP for over 60 feet building
setbacks
5of6
ATTACHMENT B
February 18, 2014 Item #5.1
Santee None forantennas up to 50 feet No Limit Not in required No limit
in height, CUP for over 50 feet building
setbacks
Solana None for antennas to40 feet in No Limit Not in required One over
Beach height, CUP if over 40 feet building 30 feet
setbacks
Vista None 100 feet Not in required No limit
building
setbacks
6 of 6 February 18, 2014 Item #5.1