Item 13 - Denial of Claim for Damages ~AGENDA REPORT SUMMARY ~
.O: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
FROM: James L. Bowersox, City Man~
INITIATED BY: John D. Fitch, Assistant City~Manager~ ,
Peggy A. Stewart, Director of Administ~ativ~Services
Douglas A. Milton, General Services Manager(~
DATE: April 4, 1995
SUBJECT: Denial of Claim for Damages -- Patricia Hodgson
Denial of Claim for Damages -- Karl and Jennifer Voepel
ABSTRACT
1. On February 23, 1995, a claim was filed with the City by Patricia Hodgson in the
amount of $406.00. Ms. Hodgson's son, Tyrone, allegedly fell in a pothole
twisting his ankle. It is recommended that this claim be denied.
2. On March 6, 1995, a claim for damages was received from Karl and Jennifer Voepel
for injuries Mr. Voepel allegedly sustained while a spectator at the Poway
SportsPark. The amount of the claim is unknown at this time. It is recommended
that the claim be denied.
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
Environmental review is not required for this agenda item according to CEQA guidelines.
FISCAL IMPACT
Unknown
ADDITIONAL PUBLIC NOTIFICATION AND CORRESPONDENCE
None
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Council deny these claims.
ACTION
II
1 of 12
'APR 4 1995 ITEM 13
- AGENDA REPOR:
CITY OF POWAY
This report is i~cluded on the Consent Calendar. There will be no separate discussion of the report pdor to approval by the
City Council unless members of the Council staff or public request it to be removed from the Consent Calendar and
discussed separately. If you v~ish to have this report pulled for discussion, please fill out a slip indicating the report number
and give it to the City Clerk pnor to the beginning of the City Council meeting.
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members ,of~ City Council
FROM: James L. Bowersox, City Mana~-~
INITIATED BY: John D. Fitch, Assistant City Manager
Peggy A. Stewart, Director of Administrativ~ Services
Douglas A. Milton, General Services Manage~'~./L_~-
DATE: April 4, 1995
SUBJECT: Denial of Claim for Damages -- Patricia Hodgson
BACKGROUND
A claim for damages was received from Ms. Patricia Hodgson on behalf of her son,
Tyrone S. Bryant. The amount of the claim to date is $406.00.
FINDINGS
Ms. Hodgson alleges that her son stepped into a pothole on Oak Knoll Road causing
him to fall and twist his ankle. Ms. Hodgson states that the hole was not visible
because it was filled with rainwater.
ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEW
Environmental review is not required for this agenda item according to CEQA
guidelines.
FISCAL IMPACT
Unknown
ADDITIONAL PUBLIC NOTIFICATION AND CORRESPONDENCE
None
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Council deny this claim.
Attachment: Claim for Damages -- Patricia Hodgson
ACTION:
2 of 12
APR 4 1995 FI'I=M 13
. � City Of Poway "` D � p ,
� b �� �
�/ ,,�/ D
cuu�e ac�vsr n� c.mr a� PowaY �E 2 3
id ir�d bjr l 1 L�/" � �' • N'AY. T
J:S. MBD _ ' �� R �'►L9At,q���
rrtsr�Ot� M�8
;�v�u ttii Coun�r �—
--�- � � y-, f - G: � �-
1 dalrn �st be �ll.d with 4�� Clty Gertc;or Ri�k Menager otrtAO Gpr:.oi Powq �rltNn i montfu;aRar whtch th�
neiidQnt or fwnt oaurrad 8f;sun your daSm Is �gninst !Ri o! Poway, not anothar p�ibtk entlry Whert
!ox 78� . Attn' �c sae� us�;sdbWona!' paporond, 6dintlfy�ortiiatlon Dy- paiaqcapA nurrib�r.� Compieted
�paeosf9l�rfflcitM, pM
iatms must be� nf�tl�d��or�detFrerod�to Th"e �Gly�ot CNte Cont�r�;D�:POway, CA. �2064�( P;G..
_ ) • AAan�ger
fO TFiE'MONORAeLE uMYOR AidD CT' COtJNE1� TFiE.CITY OF,PO'WAY CAUFORNIA _
I'h� tm0orsignod nspecttuly subrnita th� tbliowtnp elalm �nd hfomutiort e�laUv� to �amage to persons
usd/orpt�6na! property:
1. 'P1ama 0i.elalmant • t , , • .
L _ sssof dai t;
�. . Phons: o. _a Oate of'birth'
d Soelat Sewrity No. pe}v�� {��, �;
�Z Namq, tsltpAon�°tnd post offipo addrsas`to whicA dalmsnt dtairos notleog Eo be sen! R oth�r
'' �han aboye:
N a NP
3. Oetvrrence or avent from whlc�.the dalm �rrtses: ,
a. . oni� `� b. �trne � e. �ee ( �xaa tt�d spec�ic loc�Uon) . _ .
'n ak _ 1�Yta �� ��:: —'�foCr "�o c�V�i�e` )aH ri� �-trua��v�Ci Ue l'7Y� l
d Oiow and undor arhit araim"stu+c�s.did damapo or;�jury�xarr'1 SpecNy the p�rticufu
oewrr�nc@, avont, �ct oromiasion you dalm esused ths inJury, or damape (use
ed�Ft;o H nseQSSary ):
M�., s o;�' (. ) n 4� C u 0 c C) h _-{� _C�%c �,� �'.�✓e In� A'3
, l:� 0.i�'PV �S..�O��.�h.A l�1 - .�.1n 'Fh;� °�C.'f"hc�P�� ..C��O .�, C�O 1�.�'� �171>>
« :c - . f' �
OA ln ,' tTj' i S c A N °`. •
e. What par'� u'acstori b°y ` City� or Its �tnploy�es, eaused : M@ aA�pod dams9� or
injury? _
_;LG�YA:e ��P e n b a �o�C i ti, �^ae�` G� �. d vr n�
— �-IJ -- �'v' Q a rn. �` f -- ��� ?�'LI i r e (.J 0.S /U o ^�
..� ��Y' �) V�� Q�P N O� P .,
3 o f P2
APR 4 1995 I l tiiA 13
. _ _. _ _ _
6. W�!ei:a ossc�uw� v� �n� �u7� P�P�� �n8 4 Or'�&S.6o ra � 0 IVIf7��1 M Y1� Y�TIII'01 uus .
6
� slaim: � fhore war�..no k ioia. sffiis'No l�jv�s' n • �
� � 77�� S",A Y'A �.r. 1 �O Y.y G��� Qln (� .�;2�..�s .a. 0.� _�< b� t9�.e ��. �[ L\ n n�� .
� i [ /] � I 1
� �-� r�� �...�(_A'a Sf`�e L.)�a���k.c � �l. ..�a�..,� ��l�tn ����' �r � fn l �eu:.,7Y��Si�tl� ���ti
`_' �: C�tve-name(s) ot u�e`CitY •�r�tg?'�� �o d�G4 ��r1�7
� /�Dn1C •
r -
:.
0
: � etb Ydtlrlit o4'.anY otf�r �o� k�txedt
.� �. Plemo
� , a �
� .
A
:'• 7. Namo and�address ot't�o;own.aot-anr'danu0�d P�Pe�
._ A) A � Q '
.. . .
-.�
;; �. Demages daimed: , ,
a �Amount ci�lmed as�� oi`thts?date � � 0' ��
% D. Estimated.amount'of }irturo'eosts: � - o�'
e. ' Toti sisiount dalm�d: g o_ o
-
d 8uis fo� co,mputition o( amounts daim�d (°inr�udo copie�Foi al1 btue,Inwk�sr tsUn�us; �tc)
9.. N�tTlesi�111d`addCBU@E ot�8(1'rvtQfOii@i. hOSQIt�IE. dOCtOrS. stC.
� y —
� .....�.� .a •_ ,��..�'.� L. o � �. N�,-}-� e� -,.. ,,�
G .
d
10. Any additional I�tortnatlon Nai migt�t htiptyi' %� nsid �- �et�Im: I ,y
�. , .a.( �e in i N ll.w�,l��r. �
rrl� �_ � - � _� � �J o 0 �- 6 � .S h !,�/.- � i YI C E
� . 1 � 1 1. � .�.� L /�
d��e��2.�,.�.'�'� � r ��� �a� S� 71 0 ��l .Ff ee� 6� Vl�t' c I �, ��F X v� e c"r 'fz1 h:�t
9 ( •
rv - 1-n a a �. _ . l �-.� �r, s � -
.. _
� WARNING: tS 6R INAl OFFE1iSE T9 FtLE � FALSg CLt11AAl (��nal Coda ;T2;
�f liuurane� Codt ; 836:1 )
'� � nmve'e�sd.V.+e mats�es � dtu.r+�r�es �+ above etdm,a,+a',�;ta�ovdtno �sm� � ti� we, ot my own �ci,owtee�e.,
�� �ccept,as k�lortr�ation'a 9eGO1 ae fg aief+nulteia l Oe��vo t�o aamo'ti'be tnie. (conily u
� p��Y'a`D•�7:tAst Ua �r"i�oMig ffi TRUE en0 C004R8CT: • .
�t �p�d'1� ��;. Ear.of f"'21ru tf �-. -ft �
,,:
_'y� '
T. •
�� � p
Y Si�tiAlrY
;�;
� o� a,�;etic�
Po�.y, c�lo+�s�3a
cocuaaErrr r�a: . �¢.�c
4 of 12 � APR 4 1995 ITE11A 13
^ RT}10PEDIC. SURGERY ASS061ATE"� .
OF"NORTH COUNTY'
'J5525'PpMEMDO FOAD, A-1
. POWAY,,CA�IFORNW 920Q4�
IBt91�85-0050
=— � tc
�' '
�,�`" ,L`r �ccourrr No.
�\\, � j �---
S �oR
� �
.
� . ST717EMENT�DATE _ _
� r
AMOUNT REMfTTED
rn
P�ease rBNrn upq,r pprtipn wRh your remrttanCe. 7hBnk you.
BILLING G�UESTIONS?? CALL :19/485 ZS23
F'ATIENT NAME: TYRONE S PF,YANT FROM 9:00' qM TO 4:���t P�� MON T�U-F�L
Orthopedig Surgery,9sao'ciates of North Coaaty P5825 Pomerado Road,,A-1, Poway; C9 �82084 (81�4��W50
� ...
.. .• .. , . , . .. «•�. :. . .
OL=2`'-95 2 '�920: NEW'PATIENT/ INTERMED EVAL & M6MT 100:09 �
01-25-g` 2 g�3p7p AN1:LE ERACE-AIR CA$T �g,pp
OS-z5-9` 2 59058 EMEfi�ENCY IN OFFICE 44.0� �
01-25-'�` 2 76140 READING OF ;X-RAY FILM FRDM OUT5IDE SOURCE 26.00
Oi-31-95. 700 FN$URANCE HILLED p,pp
GHAMRUS CLAIMS%E%TRA Filed: t 258.00
D l�Q��
`�=,_ /
`J �
, �D���,
C ppWAY•R�K�
�M�Ni
WE BILL YOUR INSURANCE FOR SERVICES PROVIDEU. FLEASE:FEMIT YOUR PORTION WHEN DUE.
MASTERCARD AND VISA ACGEPTED BY PHONE
�
, - . � _ .. � .4_..nd_- ri �. . .. � . .
n �.� • a• r . ..�
g ',5 o f 12 395 253 : pn O.OIi 0.00 0.00 p. pn 25^0 .Oi �
rnn � +.��r ITCIIW 17.
J�v�.v�v�+� ----
� �� SECUFE HORIZONS U GSDHP
Mercy Health Centers � _; Pq � �qRElPFU PLUS G PRO CAAE
p O PACIFICAFE �(OTHEP
coven.ce. 12509 POWAY ROAD i
POWAY, CA 92064 o � T a, sa
(619)748-6 i . —
;v�nenrvyor+e��o � £133-005-0455 G NEW`PATIENT I �� � �
�
e __•— --_c.oa- �
' FIRST � � _ .M � LN�'\
V�iIENi T NI.ME ` /� �
� , �� � , "' �5 'Y00 FEE �
'� { II qys NOO FEE� E%AM
EX�M '
EXAM � INS Y00 ' FEE - wnu:'Cano �]no
� Aou�.ComY. �� �
�NEAD �AND NECK � wr4�� zna 'jt 50 �
.ww �^u r.ort on.. .ao c .
MsM�b4�Gom 101i0 VKIW���CM�� � - w � . �� p. 1]i]0
Mm VINer � :.,. _ fIViG � � � . �
�MaHaMS Omp: ]0»0 VMIatW RabW� . MvW. � '»13�
- :M�^� � °i"" ' � �SPINE� AND PELVIS o�... �ae cna: :
„.FaciLBOn�> >Oi50 . . � - _ f i 'W n . Ip�W 50 -�
�COmO Min"J H� � . �IVCM' pM. ��� �
:FUUiBOno ]0]W �P��6UT�. - ' . UnXaM.VTadMUi�' !]�W —
.wlin dblf3 vu+a IRSG �
�Na3al' oMa
10160- Cw�c�l $W�} ��� .
CO'�0'Mm � '�111IXiOt'SPM TIO]D �
v.,.�a.us��s.� � �oao _ �pWER.EXTREMITIES
ComO!Min. ] Vw .... �� �V.'�l LV R100 . —.
SYWIltE � )OAO . - NrOJNNw n �
� ina��. Nw+' - ,. 4q�eosacq�� nno - .
',Stuu Gomo. �03E0 . Sc+��. Lom iw . � Wp UN�i. Como. '�� _
�.Min��v�e. ,°... Rl)0 -
�T�mo?rrnaM�w�N� N]JO , Ri�n�,'�P H�o.•Zw �ryy�0 �!0
� � swn.c moa :o�..•�na cna. —
:tiM-KK, ]0]60: ._� m.. -: )ySW —
` �.Ti u � .. R220 �V�hnit MpYC�'b� � _
IOOG9 S�num aM Gma.Y� ... »y�p
Unlblp ROG�OYf1 _- . . �� � F��mM. - ly�
SCOIIOL� $IUOy �����
- CHEST� -. . _ �. -.. T � wo.enn�rrumu�a . ti
11oi0 � �VnlidW'?rocWun K �. = .V� n�pp q'.
'. CMn.SMw Jiw ., —
Cnm 1 V�w n020 � am�: tM . �]5!0' _
UPPER EXTREMITIES' � �"O ? °"" 1
CM11�Viw' )lOI1 �KeM��CAT4 �SSM � _
Gl�r¢I� ��� .�� � 5G _
'�CMa��V�s )tO.M: , .KnN:-�_ � ]]SM
Socuu rpG�O - ./�oaC ° '
�,^�.11Ur�IKApKa:UrLOI• )IOIt � •�� ��
� �� Fi i��1V 6 T _
... � ' 1102] SMU1Mr�1 ��� .,
G.+i.,�nOeraws . _ .... � /y,tq,ua. . .. �
-. 50w10�p(COmo. . . . 'TJ6io . �C
MvnmopfM UNUIpU 700G0 . .y���. CpM�
..AlynmoyrYn.011a1R�1 TpODt OnR �. �� 50 ;Mrb. M QT � >M�0 �� '
. - . Y M: � 1]fi.UM • . . .
mmna� 7ppp2 I4ncI�0�5a : ]J620
��'M�mm � BII�NnI . - - ulY JoIN� �� - -
i61R5. AcrvmwO� - - 9Jb]0 •
MW.,VI�w:�Mvnm. - �� Wd�Caro. ..__. .
II lOJ MVmNUa<. 001�. MO OM.. I]0.'10 �
Ri0{ Untl�lnal . .. �� � bE b. p0
1nt0 EWO.Mf�'UT i]a3] ' `
. RIM�BYY1�4 .... . �,� .fOO�:�.OmG.111CIYNIMRM- .
9U30 EIt6n'CaT0. ' — - l]6]0
. Sbmum IOwv. . � jjppp 50 . 2 VirYa �
Un1ifIW PrOCMUr� i � ��.�� C � . � � ���.
- . .. I]070 . � .. .
- ABDOMEN�. F°""'" .. . n°°°
_ � .. rnw wl wimw qx.aVn� .
�ca u+a oe� �.a�o Ntrq �P.��.UT nioo Oui�ta� Fiim� aW MISCELlANE0U5.
��aoo
_ ._ _
reua
Ul1RA50UNDiP.ROCmUiIES� �.�.u�n.�w�aao.v.ee: ��aw..
r�i.i�oe.comoi«� � TODAY'S;:CHARGES.
'rnr•maoi,a ,� - .. - .
p�lac OB: WT.. 1!!16 ' ' .
'**r�oa »u� . �� - - � DISCOUNT iJ'Piol. i6�
. . T ��� V4HCIMh55P . ..
Cn��l
w�e,.n�o6o�_ �eas. �wtv.i.uu��.nm��siwr �sx 9/o.tSCounesyi7Emo�oyee�
en..i ���i6. -- - tea.sol. ., � '.unr.`wi.i. airimw wu �u _ . .. . _ .
. _ � . . ,, .0 cu u. : wm� 7e0�o � .
doem7�ntomei.n �?nroo - - �. � SUBTOTAL
.. _ �eim '...i«ion 3..,.n . .
��AbOOm�n UAT.
°" i°°T° PREVIOUS`BALANGE
.G.��e400:i �_ . n?2o � � .
Sp�wn - ,il7'A � Unllalq ���
n:��owmo�.�m iend TOTAI. DIIE
�n.wo«�w�.�mtwr. rei�r � . .1.5�
�'� PAYMENT: 'O7 CASH '-07 MST. CHG.
'�.aia um.+o�no� . 02 CHECK :08 '/�SA�
Dx: S2y $ .
b of 12 APR 4 1995 +��
� y '' ❑CHECK �_�,2REDITCAP
� i�
•••••"�• � 11/'1Gr'IIVL
. INTERi^� MEDICINE
BILLING (��ESTIONS CALL:
1-800-723-2456
FED. ID#;33=005-0455 �rer.. soF.
�`AG. ...�PA7IENTNAME: - - .
. . � . ,.. :� SEX; OHy :
: , �',. �� I ` , : f �� � , � _' . , � : i '/
. ` �`. INSUPAN(SELOMPANY-P7i�MAFY" . ' PC j COP�Y . • ,J _
w � w ' ' � � � j � : ES: CS: BALANCE:
� :�� � � � _ .. _ �/
�A7ITENINNGBMYSICIAN: � � �SUBSCRIBEPNi ��
`-�,,..'-�� _ , � COM: SECONDARVINSU , CE:
�'\ -�.
ASSIGNEO PMVSICIAN RpLLEE FlL�:
' ��� �� � ' -.:: ., .' . y," •r _ .
e:
� OFFICESERVICES NewBL' -�ESLPL-_ PNOCEOURES - � e -
Compren;Cdn6iex 992p5 ' AnosmPY.. <6600. '�eWoOpcculi 82270. .
CcmprenlMOtlei . 9920a � , 99275 : Aitnroc Major � 20610 � Glucose Qppg3 -�
De�ai�ep . 9207�.. 992t4 '^' AuOiometry � ;9255t � Nemoqio0in i 850�8
_xoalW2dP:ob " 99ppp ,�.99zi� ,_ � Avul3io�Nail 11730 � Prgy7est �.00095'I
?,nimal 9921.T I: Cenimen Rem 69210 � ' Aapid SVeO � B64fi3 �
„obiemFOCUS �' � 99201, 992tp �, �qrnRemova� � � 9t42p UA.OiO I pp�pp' �
� •• rrYomeraW - � 17360 Venipunttflaol 36a15 I
. _ IILIECTONS� � � 930Cp � WecMOUn( 97210 I�
.AlIer9Y,MUlT 95n7 ��. ENG`raang. ..
Allerqy;SGl � � 9 � 5 � _ MEAL7MINDICATORS
� 95115 ' EXC.SkinTd9s � y�200 � �_C�olasiemlSCreenin9. 82a6
AntioiotwlM. �� � g07g8�. FIeKSigmdOOidooy Y5330 .�MammogiapnyScreenlnqRefenal tt17
)312 .. � 90792'� lid'D.A85' � 10061" :� ..'_PeP�+earfo�Cervicalbancer 8815
�.qemerol -- � 90782 �Lacera[ion: -, COOE SCAEENINGiBROCE0URE5
0T AOWt � ' � 90702 - 7ypB;; ,[ Oiabelii Eye Ezam Referral . ��.
Estroqentrc� - 90787 ��PF7' 9�W70� . � . ','�FOCalOccultBboOTesnng �
, GammaGloO � gp7a1 Pulse�Aximetry 9a760 - "" IMMUNIZ4TONS
'�Meoaiibs 8 � i 9079t Fem Foreiqn.8otly SimO�e 10720 ' � i_ Fiu Sho[ yp�Z,
MMR 9070) � .RemiNail'MamR t1750�' �_Pi+eumov3�c .gQ7�
SurqicllTray ..99070' Skin ba 11tpp. I-.Tetanus � -
so�o:
�:atlertn . 86580'? Sp�roine�ry� �94ptp:� � UNLISTEDPROCEGUNES
:Ierooe200mg '9�782�" , SuluraRemoval ggp�; �
�'<7�araDeutic � - � ..90782' ' �Trgger.Plinj� p5r�p
, _. ..�_ TymDanomeay; � ,92567 ' .
,
� . �
_AbdominalPain 799.0� f_�Carpai7un.Syndrome 354.0- [Gou� 276'9 - �L�OUtisMetlla' 3829 [�;Thrusn i�p;�
= Acne 708.1 _� CerumaqAmD���'� 380.4 [ Meatlac�e �BaA �C P�P�uUOns 785. f [ ThyroiE Dyslunnon Ze5.9
=":4i05 0a29 ^ Chemical DePenOency 9pa ��, Meadng Loss 389.1 ❑'Barkinwns 3329 � Tla' .
435,9
�_ Allergic Reaaion 995.7 ❑ Ches[ Pain 7Bfi:5 C.Mean Failura. UNS a28.9 �� Pepuc Ulcer. 535.9 ❑ Tinea Nos 1 tp,9
_,Alle�gic R�initis 4T/,9 u Con�uncwitis 372A [ Memqrrtwids 455.6 ❑ Penpherai VascWar-Dis. a4J9 ❑ ToOacca ADUSe 705. �
,_ Anemia . 285.9 � Contusion 9p4.9 [ Flepatips. Vua1 070.9 .❑ PtiSryngi�is A82 ❑ TonsJius. Acu�e a$3
_ Angma 413.9 � COPD 496A � Herpaf $impbx OSa.9 ❑ Pnyslc5l Exam V70.0 C Uremrms' S97.B
_ Aneiery, Gen. 300.02. [�Gougn 786.2 [ Fypetl{ppemie Z72A Q 7neumonia �86 .❑ Urticana 708.9
_ Am a27.9 : C DePression 31 i ❑.Mypanenwn .407:10 �] Pregnenry V22.2 ❑ URI a85.9
=,Artnreigia Nos 7t9 a � Dertnatnis'I�NOS 692.9 �.� InOVenza ae7.1 ❑ Pro3tatlCS �6p1.9 �[� U7I 599A�
_'Artnntis. Osteo 715.9 'O Diati ?ypa II wl�mpL 250 90, .G Myuinal Nemla 550.9 ❑ Reflux Eiopnagrtis 530.r .[ Vagimtis �Bt6:i
_�annnng, Rpeum 714.0 C Dia4 7ype.il w/ommpi. 250.00� [lmta0�e Bowal Syn. 56a.t ❑ qefraaive Enor 387�.9 ,_�", Valvular Hean D�s 74fi.6
_ ASCVD ap9 .0 Diiiiness 7B0�,4 ❑.Ke2rosis 702 ❑ qanal Oisortler SBB.9 ❑ Viral Sy�dmme 079,9
_ Ast�ma 493.9 [ EnCOmetrwsis 617,9 ❑ Laceratmn . ❑ Se6aoeous.Cyst 7062 1 Wans:�ural 078.�
_ AtriafFib 427.31 [j Family Planning Typ¢: ❑ Seiiura Oisorder 700.3 ❑ Weign[ LoSS 7&71
_ BaEk'Pain` 726 7ype' - COOB: �.
...._ . . . ❑Sinusros.ACUte :48t.3 �� WeIIW �A �mm V72.3
_�BPM 5pp Coae ' CLumbarDisc �g,2p �SleepOlsturbance� '7805��1 UNLS ODIP.CNOSIS
_ Br9astMass 311 72 �j� Fatgue -78p � C LymphaGanopaNy 78$.8 ❑ Sprairc -�
_&on�ni��s Acu�e' <bfi 0 ❑ Fihrocystic Braast 610 1 [ MensVUalOiyorCer 625.9' Type: -�
i
_. B�nNS 727 3 [I Gastroenierins'. .358 9 L, MySlgia 729.7 CaGe� �� � �.�
= Cancer�� ❑ Gasintis, Aa�e 535.0 � ��� I
. . [ Obesiry 278.0' U9ynwpe 7B0 2
3'�� ❑ GIBIeeC; Unsoac �5799� [Asteaparosu 793.0' ❑ Teneonitis 728.9
3 � ❑ Glaucoma 365.9 [ Otnis EatBme 380n ❑ T�romticonlebNS 451.9
, /
�nTTENDING00CTOR5IGNATUFE. �AETUFNVIS�T: TOTA�CHqRGES. � iODAV'$PAYMENT ., � �
_ 7, o f_ � 1,z I/'', 7? - - Y
l� _ CASH _ CMECK ���CIT C�F
APR 4 1995 ITE
- AGENDA REPOR:
CITY OF POWAY
This report is included on the Consent Calendar. There ~11 b~ no separate discussion of the report pdor to approval by the
City Council unless members of the Council, staff or public request {t to be removed from the Consent Calendar and
discussed separately. If you wish to have this report pulled for discussion, please fii] out a sup indicating the report number
and give it to the City Clerk pdor to the beginning of the City Council meeting.
TO: Honorable Mayor and Members of the City Council
FROM: James L. Bowersox, City Mana~T)?
INITIATED BY: John D. Fitch, Assistant City ManagerC~ ,
Peggy A. Stewart, Director of Administ~tive Services
Douglas A. Milton, General Services Manage~
DATE: April 4, 1995
SUBJECT: Denial of Claim for Damages -- Karl and Jennifer Voepel
BACKGROUND
A claim for damages was received from Karl and Jennifer Voepel on March 6, 1995.
The amount of the claim is unknown at this time.
FINDINGS
Karl Voepel claims that, while watching a volleyball match at the Poway SportsPark,
he was struck on the head by a softball that came from a ballfield behind him.
ENVIRONHENTAL REVIEW
Environmental review is not required for this agenda item according to CEQA
guidelines.
FISCAL IMPACT
Unknown
ADDITIONAL PUBLIC NOTIFICATION AND CORRESPONDENCE
None
RECOMMENDATION
It is recommended that the City Council deny this claim.
Attachment: Claim for Damages -- Karl and Jennifer Voepel
ACTION:
8 of 12
APR 4 ITEM 13
� `' 9�-9� _� 3�c
xz:
`� ;� ������� �• . �
' rsec �`����t�
R s ^ ..� Fidfas4f07W�LT# Cdt�ebaokM„s 'e
s
Donaid E. Moses RB LAVV1'ERS BLDG v.a �mv�.a>:i9�o
Carter'F. lohnston 11405 West Bernardo�Caurt, Suite, 100 {679) 487=7910
SQn Diego, CA 91117
MdrCh 3, 1995 0 � s \WPOxA01.GB]
City of Poway
RISK'MANAGEMENT DEPARTMEN'I'
PO Box 789 �y0�, � � 6'
Poway 92074-0789 � O
- w�` -
Re: Our CLients -. Karl Voepel and Jennifer Voepel. •�¢q�i
Matter » No£iae of Claim For Peraonal Injuriee�� .��
Location » Poway Sporte Park
Date of loes » 02/27�/95
Our file no: -. VG87MP
Gentlemen:
This office has been .reCained by Karl Voepel and Jennifer Voepel
wiCh regard to claims for personal injuries, prqperty damage and
loss of consortium a5 a consequence of an act of;<neglsgence of your
� agency.
The following info�ation is submitted in compYiance with Govt Code
§§910 and 910.4:
a. The name and posE office.address of the claimant:
K'ARL� YOSPBL'.AND iJ8NNIP8R V08P8L
b, The post of;fi_ce address to which the person present'ing.
the claim desires notices to be sent:
DONALD MOSES
A 'PROYSS9IONAL I.AW CORPORATZON
, ... .
���114Q$' F1B9T SSRNARDO COIIRT!� $IIITB� 100
SriN Dxaao, CA 92127
�ANY�DSFffi79H'�,•A3'TO THS SIIPPICIffi1CY OP THI9 CLAIM BA98D IIPON A�DSFSCT
'OR� OMI99ION� ZN 'THS CLAZM' A9 'YRBSffiiTBD 9PII.L HH YiASVBD SY YOII A9 �A
.MATTSR� �OP� LAW' [GOVT '�.'ODB�; �911. ] DNLH39. YOII� 9SND NOTSCB OF 9IIC8
INSIIPPICISNCY;'1fITH 'R89YHCT' TO 3IICH DBFBCT OR OSIS9ZON TO:
DONALD E. MOSES
A ,PR088$$IONAL LAW CORPORATION..
1140 WssT Haxtraxno Counr, Svxxs 100
� ST.x Dzsco, CA 92127-
c. The date, place and other circumstances of the occurrence
9 of 12
APR 4 �g95 ITEM 13
March 3, 1995
Page -2-
or transaction which gave rise to the claim asserted:
ON 02/27/95 AT ABOUT ? :45 PM, KARL VOEPRL WAS WATCHING A VOLLEY BALL
GAME WHILE SITTING AT A PICNIC TABLE AT T~B POWAY SPORTS PA~K WHEN
HE WAS STRUCK IN TEE BACK OF T~E HEAD BY A LiNE DRIVE SOFT BALL HIT
FROM A BALL FIELD BBMIND HIM. THERE WAS ONLY A LOW FENCE SEPARATING
TEE BALL PA~K FROM TEE PICNIC TABLE WHERE ~R. VOEPRL WAS SITTING.
THE CITY OF POWAY WAS NEGLIGENT IN FAILING TO SITUAT~ TEE REST AREA
IN A SAFER PLACE, AND/OR IN FAILING TO SEPARATE TEE PLAYING FIELD
WITE A PROTECTIVE SCREEN.
d. A general description of the indebtedness, obligation,
injury, damage or loss incurred so far as it may be known at the
time of presentation of the claim:
I19~u~ES AND ~ICAL EXPENSES: KA~L VOEP~L ~u~,~l:) CUTS TO T~ TOp
OF TEE HEAD~ WHICH BLED PROFUSELy AT TH~ SCENE AND HE HAS ALSO
SUFFERED FROM MEAD, NECK AND BACK PAINS ~V~R SINCE. INJURIES ALSO
INCLUDE POST TRAUMATIC STRESS DISOP. DER AND INk,TRIES TO MIS NECK.
ALSO HAS CONCUSSION MANIFESTED BY HEADACHES, NAUSHA, TINNITUS AND
DIZZINESS. THE FULL EXTENT OF THE I~u~IBS ARE NOT YET KNOWN. AS
A FURTEER PROXIHATE RESULT OF THE NEGLIGENCE IN QUESTION, JENNIFER
V0EPEL SUFFERED LOSS OF CONSORTIUM. WE WILL PROVIDE YOU WITE
DOCUMENTATION SUPPORTING AND EX~OUNDIN~ UPON THESE INJ~IRIES AS IT IS
RECEIVED.
LOST EAP-NING CAPACITY: KArL VOEPBL iS ~wDLOY~D BY 'r~ ~RIT~D STAT~S
GOVEP. NMENT AS A SERGEANT IN '£a~ UNITBD STATES ~%RINES. HE HAS LOST
TIME FROM MIS JOB DUTIES AND THE INJURIES CAUSED BY TEE NEGLIGENCE
IN QUESTION HAVE PREVENTED SIM FROM PERFORMING HIS ASSIGNED TASKS
WITEOUT IMPOSIN~ UPON MIS CO- WOP. K~RS. ~%DDITIONAL LOST EArNINgS ARE
ANTICIPATED.
e. The name or names of the public employee or employees
causing the injury, damage, or loss, if known:
UNKNOWN. H0~¢EVER, I RBQUFST THAT YOU CHECK TEE SCHEDULBS AND
PROVIDE ME WITE TEIS r~FORMATION.
f. The amount claimed as of the date of presentation of the
claim, including the estimated amount of any prospective injury,
damage, or loss, insofar as it may be known at the time of the
presentation of the claim, together with the basis of computation
of the amount claimed. If the amount claimed exceeds ten thousand
lO of 12 APR 4 1995 ITEM
City Of Poway
RISK MANAGEMENT DEPARTMENT
March 3, 1995
Page -3-
dollars ($10,000), no dollar amount shall be included in the claim.
However, it shall indicate whether jurisdiction over the claim
would rest in municipal or superior court.
THE ~umL EXTENT OF TH~ INJURIES AR~ NOT YET KNOWN .... TH~ SYMPTOMS
ARE OF SIGNIFICANT IIv~-mNSZTY, AND ~UG~EST A SERIOUS CONDITION.
ACCORDINGLY, OUR FOP~AL CLAIM FOR TH~ PERSONAL INJURY ASPECT OF THIS
CLAIM IS IN EXCESS OF $10,000, AND JURISDICTION OVER THE CLAIM WILL
RZST IN SUPERIOR COURT.
Please acknowledge this claim in writing, and advise me of the
claim number and the name and address of your representativ~ to
whom I should address future correspondence concerning this claim.
This letter constitutes an attorney's lien against the proceeds of
any settlement resulting from this claim.
This letter is submitted and signed in behalf of Karl Voepel and
Jennifer Voepel and intended to satisfy Govt Code §900 et seq.
Yours very trul~
11 of 12 APR 4 1995 ITEM
CE IFICATE OF INSURANCE
AN~ ~NFERS NO RIG~ ~ON THE CE~IFICATE
HO~ER. ~15 CE~IFI~
~ M~GN~V07, ~AY ~ ALTE~ ~ ~E A~O~D ~' ~E PO~l~ ~EL~.
,~T ~AY~[, [~ ~6~u,z COMPANIES A~ORDING COVERAGE
~'!" ~ OF c~O~z~ ~;~ .......
SOX 769 k~n ..............
pO~A'I, CA 9=07~ ' COMPLY ~
Gena~ ~g.eat~ NO~E
' - ~ aile Li~fli~ [OOO
[] S~u~ auras T7-362400~ 01/L3/95 01/13/96
~ ~,,ed auto~ 12:01 a.m. 12:0[
m~ ~B-36240023 01/13/9! 01/13/96 2000
~0~herman UmOre'a ;Ol m.~.
PER'OCC~NCE FOR ~N ........... .~ .~ . =n ~ aW~K ~%SI~G OUT OF ~E BATTING
~' ~00 O0 PE~ OCCU~'CE D~UCTLBLg ~rm&~ ~u ~ ~
. C&~ ,~*~~ . ~TION
CE~IFICA~ ~ HOLD~
SHOULO ~Y OF THE AeOVU Ug~Ca[eED POLICIES BE
~CEL~D ~E~RE ~E ~ATION